Saturday 26 May 2012

Is a rabbit less sentient than a cat or dog?


European Directive 86/609/EEC that was implemented into U.K. legislation through the introduction of Animals (Scientific Procedures) Act 1986 is to be replaced by European Directive 2010/63/EU. This new Directive came into force in November 2010, but, as is usual, a two year period is allowed for drafting of transposing legislation which must be completed by November 10th this year and implemented by 1st January 2013. The transposing legislation is said to be taking into account a large public and interested body consultation.
The new legislation is to iron out the variations in the previous implementation process and to strengthen the “3Rs”: Replace, reduce and refine, of the use of animals in scientific research. However, the U.K. Government intends to retain current, stricter standards, which exceed Annex III to the Directive, and retain special protection for dogs, cats and horses, and non-human primates.
Worryingly, the U.K. Government wishes to explore opportunities to simplify the detail of personal licence authorities, while reassuring us that this will not lead to a reduction in protection. The U.K. will not be implementing less frequent inspections than are currently undertaken in the UK.
Vet Juris welcomes any legislation that enhances the welfare of animals. However, we are puzzled; what moral or ethical code would allow rats, rabbits, ferrets, mice and other mammals to be subjected conditions or to experimental procedures that are too noxious for cats, dogs, equids and non-human primates? Is this just species-ism? Maybe, rabbits and the such just don’t mind having cosmetics and cleaning products put in their eyes.


The Government's plans can be seen at this web site:
www.homeoffice.gov.uk/publications/about-us/consultations/transposition-protection-animals/

The full text of the Directive can be seen at this web site:


Stop press.
The government are now considering legislation to allow stray, unclaimed pets to be used in scientific research; despite the above assurances.

© VJ 2012

Sunday 6 May 2012

Update on Dr (now Professor) Blass

Today Vet Juris has contacted Professor Eddie Blass at the Swinburne University of Technology in Melbourne, Australia and asked her for her comments. We will let this story lie for a few weeks, a few of my contacts have been made via snail mail so Vet Juris will wait and see what sort of responses we receive before making any further comment.

VJ (C) 2012